Wealth Compass
Dear Reader,
One of the sharpest people I have known ran a large manufacturing plant for over two decades. He kept a spreadsheet for everything, from production costs to the family’s grocery bills.
In March 2020, as markets fell, he called me. “I have studied the data,” he said. “This time is different. I am moving everything to fixed deposits.”
He did. Over the next eighteen months, the Sensex gained over 130% from its March 2020 low. He went back in late, at much higher levels.
He was not short of intelligence. He had more data than most. What he lacked was not information. It was a written plan, made in calm times, that he could trust more than his fear.
This issue is about why even intelligent people make poor financial decisions, and why the cure is rarely more intelligence.
This is an illustrative story, drawn from a pattern I have seen many times, and not about any particular individual. Nor is this issue a judgement on anyone’s intelligence. The mistakes it describes are human ones, and none of us, myself included, is immune to them.
Why Even Intelligent People Make Poor Financial Decisions.
When intelligence is not enough to make you a smart investor.
1. The Intelligence Paradox.
They run businesses, lead teams, solve complex problems and analyse data for a living. Highly educated professionals, successful entrepreneurs, senior executives, and even people who understand finance well. Yet when it comes to their own money, many of them:
- Buy high and sell low.
- Chase the latest investment fad.
- Hold on to losing investments for years.
- Panic when markets correct.
- Invest on tips rather than fundamentals.
- Confuse activity with progress.
Being intelligent helps you understand financial information. It does not necessarily help you control your behaviour.
2. Intelligence Often Creates Overconfidence.
Intelligent people are used to being right. Their professional success reinforces their confidence in their own judgement. That confidence becomes dangerous when they enter unfamiliar territory.
- An accomplished businessman believes he can time the stock market.
- A senior executive starts picking individual stocks after reading a few reports.
- A successful professional believes he can outperform experienced fund managers.
The numbers are humbling. SEBI’s study of over one crore individual traders in equity futures and options found that 93% of them lost money between FY22 and FY24, with an average loss of around Rs 2 lakh per trader, including transaction costs. More than 75% of those who lost money kept trading anyway.
Source: SEBI study on individual F&O traders, September 2024.
The problem is not a lack of intelligence. It is the inability to recognise the limits of one’s knowledge.
Sometimes, the smarter we think we are, the harder it becomes to admit that we could be wrong.
Enjoying Wealth Compass? It is free, every week, straight to your inbox.
3. The Trap of Emotional Investing.
Financial decisions are rarely as rational as we would like to believe. Three emotions do most of the damage.
|
Fear Selling investments during market corrections. |
Greed Chasing assets that have already delivered extraordinary returns. |
Regret Holding on to poor investments because selling would mean admitting a mistake. |
The same investor can be euphoric in a bull market and despairing in a correction, while nothing about their goals or time horizon has changed. Only the mood has.
Markets test your temperament more often than your intelligence.
4. Information Overload. Knowing More, Understanding Less.
Financial information is everywhere. Business channels, YouTube, social media, WhatsApp groups, market experts and investment influencers offer opinions around the clock. Intelligent investors often consume too much of it. They:
- Keep changing their investment strategy.
- React to every market prediction.
- Confuse information with knowledge.
- Mistake a convincing narrative for a sound investment decision.
More information does not necessarily lead to better decisions. Sometimes, it simply creates more confusion.
5. The Complexity Trap.
Intelligent people often assume that a sophisticated strategy must deliver better results. Over time, they accumulate:
- Too many mutual fund schemes.
- Multiple portfolio strategies.
- Sectoral and thematic funds.
- Direct stocks that overlap with their mutual funds.
- Complex products they barely understand.
Eventually, the portfolio becomes difficult to monitor and manage. A simple, well-diversified portfolio with the right asset allocation often serves an investor better than an unnecessarily complicated one.
Complexity is not the same as sophistication.
6. The Sunk Cost Fallacy. Refusing to Accept Mistakes.
One of the most expensive financial mistakes is holding on to a bad investment simply because you have already put a lot into it. For example:
- Refusing to sell a fundamentally weak stock because it has fallen 40%.
- Continuing with an underperforming strategy because you have followed it for years.
- Investing more just to average down, without reassessing why you bought it in the first place.
Intelligent people often find it particularly difficult to accept that their earlier judgement was wrong.
Your past investment decision should not dictate your future investment decision.
7. Confusing Wealth Creation With Wealth Preservation.
Many investors spend years accumulating wealth and very little time understanding how to protect it. They:
- Take excessive risks even after their financial goals are secured.
- Have no clear asset allocation.
- Ignore their liquidity needs.
- Overlook estate planning and succession.
- Fail to prepare for withdrawals in retirement.
The real objective is not simply to maximise returns. It is to achieve your financial goals without taking unnecessary risks.
The purpose of investing is not to win a return competition. It is to achieve financial independence.
8. The Biggest Mistake. No Investment Discipline.
Intelligent investors often spend hours analysing investments and almost no time creating rules for their own behaviour. A disciplined investor has clear answers to six questions.
Why am I investing?
What is my investment horizon?
What asset allocation is appropriate for me?
How much risk can I genuinely tolerate?
Under what circumstances should I change my strategy?
Am I investing according to a plan, or reacting to market noise?
A written investment plan can protect investors from their own impulsive decisions.
9. How to Become a Smarter Investor.
Accept that you cannot predict markets.
Focus on what you can control.
Keep your portfolio simple.
Invest with purpose, not complexity.
Separate emotions from decisions.
Avoid reacting to short-term market movements.
Have a clearly defined asset allocation.
Rebalance rather than constantly reinventing your portfolio.
Know when to seek help.
Being intelligent does not mean you have to do everything yourself.
The Thought I Want to Leave You With.
The biggest risk to an investor’s wealth is not always the stock market, economic uncertainty or geopolitical developments. Sometimes, it is the investor himself.
Intelligence can help you understand the markets, analyse businesses and evaluate opportunities. But building wealth requires something more: patience, discipline, humility and the ability to control your emotions.
You don’t have to be the smartest person in the room to become a successful investor.
You just have to avoid the mistakes that even intelligent people often make.
Diversification Is Not About Owning More Assets. It Is About Owning Assets That Behave Differently.
What 10 years of Indian market data tells us about Equity, Debt, Gold and Silver.
Most investors understand the importance of diversification. Yet the discussion often revolves around investing in more mutual fund schemes, adding more stocks or spreading investments across different fund categories. But is that really diversification? True diversification is not simply about owning more investments. It is about combining asset classes that respond differently to changing economic and market conditions.
| Financial year | Gold | Nifty 50 TRI |
|---|---|---|
| FY 2009 | 24.4% | -35.4% |
| FY 2012 | 32.9% | -8.2% |
| FY 2016 | 10.9% | -7.8% |
| FY 2020 | 29.7% | -25.0% |
| FY 2023 | 16.6% | 0.6% |
| FY 2025 | 32.2% | 6.6% |
There have been several periods when equities struggled while gold delivered positive returns. Gold has not always outperformed equity, but it has often provided a counterbalance during difficult equity markets. Equally, there have been periods when equities delivered strong returns while gold remained subdued. No single asset class consistently leads the performance chart.
Correlation runs from -1 to +1. A value of +1 means two assets move perfectly together, 0 means no meaningful relationship, and -1 means they move in opposite directions.
| Asset class | Correlation with equity | Annualised volatility |
|---|---|---|
| Equity | 1.00 | 16.04% |
| Debt | 0.11 | 2.66% |
| Gold | -0.06 | 13.24% |
| Silver | 0.10 | 25.83% |
Gold and silver had a correlation of 0.77, so they tend to move together.
Silver, despite its low correlation with equity, was the most volatile of the four. An asset can provide diversification benefits without necessarily being a low-risk investment.
A portfolio of 60% equity and 40% debt behaves differently from one of 60% equity, 25% debt, 10% gold and 5% silver. Diversification does not eliminate risk or guarantee positive returns, and correlations change over time, particularly during periods of market stress.
The takeaway. Don’t diversify merely by increasing the number of investments in your portfolio. Diversify by combining assets that bring different strengths to the table.
Source: Edelweiss Mutual Fund, data as on 31 January 2026. Correlation and volatility cover January 2016 to January 2026. Equity is the Nifty 50 TRI, debt is the CRISIL Composite Short Term Bond Index, and gold and silver are domestic prices.
The Mental Accounting Trap. Why Your FD Earns Less Than Your Loan Costs.
You have Rs 5 lakh in a fixed deposit, kept aside for safety. At the same time, you are paying EMIs on a personal loan, or carrying a balance on your credit card. The FD earns interest. The loan charges far more.
Behavioural economists call this mental accounting: treating money differently depending on which mental bucket we have placed it in, even though every rupee is the same.
The relevant question is not “Which account is this money in?” It is “If all my money sat in one place, would I keep paying more interest than I earn?”
An emergency fund is sensible. But savings beyond that, sitting in an FD while a costlier loan runs, quietly cost you the difference every year.
The action this week. List your loans and their interest rates next to your savings and what they earn. Where a loan costs more than your savings earn, consider prepaying it, after keeping your emergency fund intact.
The Anchoring Trap. Why We Get Stuck on a Number That No Longer Matters.
You decided to invest once the Nifty fell back to a level you had seen a year ago. It never did, and the money stayed in your savings account. Or you refuse to sell a flat for less than you paid, while it keeps costing you maintenance, taxes and the returns the money could have earned elsewhere.
Behavioural economists call this anchoring: fixing on a reference number, often an old price, and letting it drive decisions that should rest on today’s facts.
The relevant question is not “What did it cost before?” It is “If I had never seen that number, what would I decide today?”
Markets and property do not know the price you paid or the level you are waiting for. Your goals and time horizon are the only reference points that matter.
The action this week. Find one decision you have been postponing until a particular price or level returns. Ask whether that number has anything to do with your goals.
Free Consultation
Smart Enough to Want a Second Opinion?
A 20-minute conversation can help you put a written plan in place, simplify your portfolio and set rules for your own behaviour before the next market fall. No obligation. No products. Just clarity.
Our Specialisation
We work with serving and retiring Armed Forces officers, NRIs, and salaried professionals to bring clarity and structure to their investments, aligned with their goals, time horizons, and risk profile.
Limited slots each week. Book early.
Found this useful? Subscribe to Wealth Compass free every week.
Missed an earlier issue? Browse all past editions →
Col. Rakesh Goyal (Retd.)
Certified Financial Planner · LetsInvestWisely · Gurgaon
MFD · ARN 148124
A3-103, Plaza at 106, Sector 106
Gurugram 122017, Haryana, India
For educational purposes only. Not an investment advice of any kind.
AMFI-Registered Mutual Fund Distributor. Investments are subject to market risks.
Please read all scheme-related documents carefully before investing.
